Harry Potter Butterbeer Italian Soda with Torani! One of the best sounding items from Harry Potter is Butterbeer...it's a creamy, delightful dessert drink--that the Hogwarts crew cannot get enough of! There's a million ways to make it, some more complicated than others...but I'm going to show you the Italian Soda/Dirty Drink version. It's so simple and just takes 3 ingredients...all non-alcoholic. You will need: Torani Syrup in Butter Rum or Butterscotch (I was not compensated for these syrups, I bought them myself) Cream Soda Half & Half We tested the Butter Rum and the Butterscotch. 4 out of 5 of us prefer the Butter Rum. Butterscotch has a very sweet flavor with a sweet beverage. Butter Rum has a deeper undertone. So we pick the Butter Rum, but maybe let your guests decide! Add 1 pump of syrup 7-8 ounces of Cream Soda 1 Tablespoon of half & half The half in half swirls and does a little dance before clouding the drink and making